Read Parts 1 and 2 Here!
The second part of this assignment that was important to me was to speak with students at the high school I am now observing at. I asked them some of the same questions I did of my teacher regarding motivation. I wanted to know what motivates them to do well in school, how teachers and classes contribute to this, and what they feel like the overall attitude towards school is in their community.
While speaking to the students they said that, interestingly enough, their friends were the main motivating factor in their lives. They explained that if someone they know is taking a harder class or getting involved in an organization, they can be convinced to do so also. They also said that they are very competitive with friends over grades, so it is important for them to not fall behind what other people are achieving. I think it is important to point out here that the group of eight students I spoke to volunteered to help me out and were (by a quick and informal poll while we spoke) all members of varsity sports, NHS, or some type of extra-curricular organization. I assume that the fact that these were academically high-achieving and involved students has an effect on their answers to my questions.
Some of their advice to me as a new teacher was that lectures and discussions were the best format for Social Studies classes. When I asked why, they told me that Social Studies is one of the only times during the day that they get to have much an opinion on subjects, and that they enjoy being able to do so. They also said that the most frustrating things a teacher can do are to not know the information they are teaching, or to not return assignments or grades back to them in a reasonable amount of time.
One of the things that I have working in my favor as a brand-new teacher is that I still completely understand what it is like to be a student. I could relate to what these students had to say about their experiences much easier than I could to what my host teacher had to say. Both had wonderful and insightful advice for me and I think keeping a balance between the teacher side of me and the student side of me will be key to my own success.
Showing posts with label Assignments. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Assignments. Show all posts
April 08, 2011
April 06, 2011
Questions, Questions: Part 2
This will make more sense if you read this first!
As most things regarding education seem to do, the more answers I hear, the more questions I end up having. Recently, I was able to sit down with my host teacher and have a discussion about motivation. Most importantly, I was interested in seeing what she had to say about how she motivates her students, and how effective those methods seem to be. According to my teacher, the easiest and most prevalent way teachers motivate students and show progress are through grades. She explained that she feels that most students at our school feel that just passing classes is enough, and that there doesn't seem to be much of a desire to excel beyond that by the majority of students. In our class, her policy for late work is much more lenient than some other teachers in the school. My teachers allows students almost the entire trimester to get homework assignments turned into her for at least partial credit. According to her this, coupled with a regular email update to parents every week, encourages the students to finish most of their assignments. Her most salient advice to me was the importance of follow through. She said that whatever policies I establish need to be adhered to in all cases, and similarly at all times. I think this is great advice because it allows to establish a precedent within my classroom.
An interesting thing that my host teacher brought up is that she tries to use positive encouragement sparingly. Her reasoning was that if a student answers a question and you tell them that it was a "great answer", then it discourages other students from answering, or from that student pushing past their initial answer. I have very mixed feelings about this approach. I can see what she is saying but I feel like you can still validate and praise all answers, while still pushing students. I personally am a very positive person, so it would be difficult for me to take this approach. I have noticed that she does not use positive verbal encouragement very often with her students and have wondered how it effects her relationship with them.
Something that struck me during our interview that my teacher said several time was that, "we don't have kids that go to Harvard" when talking about the student population at our school. There is a very wide economic gap within the community, but our school has honor roll, AP classes, honors credits, and National Honor Society just like most other high schools. She also mentioned that her own children who attended the school were part of groups of friends that were very academically gifted and high achieving. That being said, she meant that even the smartest students do not attend Ivy League schools. This comment really confuses me because I don't understand how there could be a vacuum of Ivy League material students in this one community. Both of these comments make me wonder more about how my teacher actually views her students. I don't get the impression she thinks of them as adults (or at least on their way to being adults). It is hard to tell whether this is from the community, her age difference from the students, or her personal style.
As most things regarding education seem to do, the more answers I hear, the more questions I end up having. Recently, I was able to sit down with my host teacher and have a discussion about motivation. Most importantly, I was interested in seeing what she had to say about how she motivates her students, and how effective those methods seem to be. According to my teacher, the easiest and most prevalent way teachers motivate students and show progress are through grades. She explained that she feels that most students at our school feel that just passing classes is enough, and that there doesn't seem to be much of a desire to excel beyond that by the majority of students. In our class, her policy for late work is much more lenient than some other teachers in the school. My teachers allows students almost the entire trimester to get homework assignments turned into her for at least partial credit. According to her this, coupled with a regular email update to parents every week, encourages the students to finish most of their assignments. Her most salient advice to me was the importance of follow through. She said that whatever policies I establish need to be adhered to in all cases, and similarly at all times. I think this is great advice because it allows to establish a precedent within my classroom.
An interesting thing that my host teacher brought up is that she tries to use positive encouragement sparingly. Her reasoning was that if a student answers a question and you tell them that it was a "great answer", then it discourages other students from answering, or from that student pushing past their initial answer. I have very mixed feelings about this approach. I can see what she is saying but I feel like you can still validate and praise all answers, while still pushing students. I personally am a very positive person, so it would be difficult for me to take this approach. I have noticed that she does not use positive verbal encouragement very often with her students and have wondered how it effects her relationship with them.
Something that struck me during our interview that my teacher said several time was that, "we don't have kids that go to Harvard" when talking about the student population at our school. There is a very wide economic gap within the community, but our school has honor roll, AP classes, honors credits, and National Honor Society just like most other high schools. She also mentioned that her own children who attended the school were part of groups of friends that were very academically gifted and high achieving. That being said, she meant that even the smartest students do not attend Ivy League schools. This comment really confuses me because I don't understand how there could be a vacuum of Ivy League material students in this one community. Both of these comments make me wonder more about how my teacher actually views her students. I don't get the impression she thinks of them as adults (or at least on their way to being adults). It is hard to tell whether this is from the community, her age difference from the students, or her personal style.
April 04, 2011
Questions, Questions: Part 1
A large portion of one of the classes I am currently taking revolves around our time spent placed in a local high school. For five hours each week I observe and participate in a classroom with high school Juniors and Seniors. With respect to everyone's privacy, the name of the school, students, and teachers will be left out. For an assignment, we had to act as a 'participant observer' to further explore an aspect of the school that interested, confused, or concerned us. I decided to interview my host teacher and some of our students regarding questions I had about motivation.
The reason I chose the topic of motivation, and how it is fostered, is two-fold. First, the atmosphere regarding motivation and enthusiasm about schoolwork was very different at this school than anywhere I had personally attended or observed. To me, many of the students were not passionate about school or interested in their classes. Having worked and tutored in mostly urban schools prior to this placement, this attitude was not completely new to me. High School is a difficult time for students for a host of different reasons. Unfortunately, popularity and personal issues often get in the way of education. That being said, the students at the school I am currently placed at were very different to me. There seemed to be a greater deal of apathy and disinterest than at other schools. In an urban setting, there are great amounts of passion, it is just usually not placed towards school. At my current placement, students didn't seem moved one way or another. They showed up because they 'had' to and for no other reason. The second reason I chose this is because, as a teacher, it is the aspect of classroom management that scares me most. How do I encourage students and convince them how important education is?
To keep my own thoughts organized, I plan on completing this analysis in three parts. This first entry being my intentions and thought process, the second will be about my discussion with my host teacher, and the third will be about my interview with students. Hopefully I can shed some light on this complicated issue.
The reason I chose the topic of motivation, and how it is fostered, is two-fold. First, the atmosphere regarding motivation and enthusiasm about schoolwork was very different at this school than anywhere I had personally attended or observed. To me, many of the students were not passionate about school or interested in their classes. Having worked and tutored in mostly urban schools prior to this placement, this attitude was not completely new to me. High School is a difficult time for students for a host of different reasons. Unfortunately, popularity and personal issues often get in the way of education. That being said, the students at the school I am currently placed at were very different to me. There seemed to be a greater deal of apathy and disinterest than at other schools. In an urban setting, there are great amounts of passion, it is just usually not placed towards school. At my current placement, students didn't seem moved one way or another. They showed up because they 'had' to and for no other reason. The second reason I chose this is because, as a teacher, it is the aspect of classroom management that scares me most. How do I encourage students and convince them how important education is?
To keep my own thoughts organized, I plan on completing this analysis in three parts. This first entry being my intentions and thought process, the second will be about my discussion with my host teacher, and the third will be about my interview with students. Hopefully I can shed some light on this complicated issue.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)